Skip to content

Everton go fifth as Thierno Barry double sinks Coventry

Barry now has 10 goals for the season and is reported to sit just behind Erling Haaland, while Coventry are left with several VAR decisions to dispute.

By Sportsback
FC RB Salzburg versus SV Mattersburg (4. Juli 2019)Werner100359 · CC BY-SA 4.0

Everton came from behind to beat Coventry 3-1 and moved to fifth in the Premier League, with Thierno Barry scoring twice and setting up another goal. It was Everton's third consecutive win under David Moyes. Barry's double took his tally for the season to 10 goals in all competitions.

That total is reported to place him just behind Erling Haaland in the scoring chart. Fifth place and a striker in that company were not the expected returns from a transfer window that drew heavy criticism at the time, and the gap between that expectation and the current table is the story of Everton's autumn.

2025/26
English Premier League badge
Premier LeagueEngland
Season 2025/26Sportsback

Coventry's grievances

FC RB Salzburg v. Wolfsberger AC (10. August 2019)Werner100359 · CC BY-SA 4.0
FC RB Salzburg v. Wolfsberger AC (10. August 2019)

Frank Lampard, who previously managed Everton, spent the night watching decisions go against his Coventry side. Reports describe two strong penalty appeals being rejected; other accounts count three major VAR calls going against them. The two versions differ, and nobody involved has confirmed the exact number.

The manner of Barry's second goal adds to the complaint. It is reported that the ball appeared to come off his arm on its way in. If that is how it happened, it sits alongside the rejected penalty appeals as the central frustration of Coventry's evening.

Dewsbury-Hall settles it

Paris Saint-Germain - Manchester City FC, 22 January 2025Like tears in rain · CC BY-SA 4.0
Paris Saint-Germain - Manchester City FC, 22 January 2025

Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall scored Everton's third goal late on to end Coventry's resistance. Coming after Barry's two, it turned a narrow and contested lead into a scoreline that flatters nobody's account of the night. Everton had to come from behind to get there, and the win was their third in a row.

What is not yet known

Neither club has commented publicly on the officiating. No explanation has been offered for why the penalty appeals were turned down, and it has not been confirmed whether the incident involving Barry's arm was reviewed. Coventry's goalscorer and the timing of the goals have not been established, and Barry's season tally beyond the figure reported after this match has not been independently set out.

Why fifth place matters

Everton's position reflects a run rather than a single result: three straight wins and a centre-forward on 10 goals by early November. The table will shift again as the rest of the round is played, so fifth is a snapshot rather than a settled placing. Coventry leave with nothing and with a set of decisions they believe cost them.

Frequently asked questions

What was the score between Everton and Coventry?
Everton won 3-1 after falling behind, with Thierno Barry scoring twice and Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall adding a late third goal.
How many goals has Thierno Barry scored this season?
His double against Coventry took him to 10 goals for the season in all competitions. He is reported to sit just behind Erling Haaland in the scoring chart.
Why were Coventry unhappy with the decisions at Everton?
It is reported that two strong penalty appeals were rejected, and that Barry's second goal appeared to come off his arm. Some accounts put the number of VAR calls going against Coventry at three rather than two.
Who manages Coventry?
Frank Lampard, who was managing against his former club Everton. His side led at one stage before conceding three times.
Where are Everton in the Premier League table?
Everton are fifth following their third win in a row. The placing could change once the rest of the round is completed.

Related stories